Skip to content

Internet Explorer is no longer supported by this website.

For optimal browsing we recommend using Chrome, Firefox or Safari.

Publications

High Court Opts for Incremental Approach to LGBT Issues

July 2019

The 2017-2018 term’s decision in Masterpiece Cakeshop Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission left many advocates for LGBT rights with mixed emotions: relief that the U.S. Supreme Court avoided a broad free speech ruling that would have been tantamount to a license to discriminate; concern that the court deemed it a close case; and uncertainty about the future of LGBT rights. The retirement of long-time LGBT rights ally Justice Anthony Kennedy soon thereafter led some to fear for the worst.

Yet, for all the consequential decisions of the 2018-2019 Supreme Court term — ranging from census questions to vulgar trademarks and gerrymandering — the court charted a rather restrained course on LGBT issues. To be sure, the forecast remains worrisome and challenging issues remain. But the court as a whole has not signaled hostility to the hard-earned progress of recent years, opting instead for an incremental approach.

Read the article here.