New Law Offers Additional Flexibility in Structuring LLC Management
New Law Offers Additional Flexibility in Structuring LLC Management
This Client Advisory is part of a series highlighting different features of the Ohio LLC Act that goes into effect on January 1, 2022.* For other content regarding the Act, click here.
*Note: The effective date has been delayed until February 11, 2022.
A new Ohio LLC statute will bring flexibility in structuring the management of a limited liability company formed in Ohio. Current Ohio law contemplates that an LLC will be managed either directly by its owners, known as “members,” or by designated persons called “managers.” Until 2016, the Ohio LLC statute did not even officially contemplate the concept of “officers” as an option. Even today it does not expressly contemplate governance by a collective group like a board of directors.
No longer just “member-managed” or “manager-managed.” Drafters of LLC operating agreements have long provided for boards of managers and officers answerable to that board when it suited the management structure desired by the members, but this structure relied heavily on the idea that such a contract among the members would be honored even if not directly contemplated by the statute. Beginning January 1, 2022, the new Ohio Revised Limited Liability Company Act will move away from the concept that an LLC is either “member-managed” or “manager-managed.” Although the new Act still uses the term “manager,” it will now be defined as “any person designated by the limited liability company or its members with the authority to manage all or part of the activities or affairs of the limited liability company on behalf of the limited liability company, which person has agreed to serve in such capacity, whether such person is designated as a manager, director, officer, or otherwise.”
Existing authority to bind. Existing Ohio law provides that in an LLC without managers, each member, acting alone, can bind the LLC in a matter “apparently carrying on in the usual way the business of the company” unless the other person knows that the member does not have the necessary authority. Similarly, under existing law in an LLC with managers, each manager, acting separately, can bind the LLC in apparently carrying on in the usual way the business of the company unless the other party knows that the manager does not have actual authority. Thus an LLC under today’s law is at risk that a member or manager who oversteps his or her bounds could commit the LLC to a third party who is ignorant of the lack of actual authority of the member or manager.
New reliance on actual authority. The new statute replaces those standards with the simple concept that no person has the power to bind the LLC except to the extent the person is authorized to act as the agent of the LLC under the operating agreement or such authorization is provided to the person by the members in a manner that does not violate the operating agreement. For actions in the ordinary course of activities of the LLC, approval by a majority of members is sufficient, but for actions not in the ordinary course of activities of the LLC, the approval must be unanimous. In other words, only actual authority granted as provided by, or pursuant to, the governing document or by express vote of the members results in binding effect. That actual authority could be provided directly by the operating agreement; by delineating certain actions a person is authorized to take, indirectly, such as by stating that a person has authority to the extent conferred by a board of directors; or by an action of the members as described above.
The new importance of actual authority means that a person entering into an agreement with an Ohio LLC may want to look more closely into governing documents to be assured that the person signing for the LLC has the actual authority to do so.
In our experience, most operating agreements today have express provisions that lay out the authority structure of the company. If, however, an LLC has relied on the existing statutory provisions to set the authority of members or managers to bind the company, that concept will need to be revisited, because, when the new law goes into effect, there may no longer be any effective structure for decisions to bind the company.
The new law also, for the first time in Ohio, authorizes an LLC to establish separate series that may hold separate assets and limit their liability to the activities of the specific series. Each series can have a separate management structure. For more about series LLCs, see our Client Advisory here.
Also for the first time, the new statute provides the option for an LLC to file a “statement of authority” with the Ohio Secretary of State. A statement of authority may address authority for the LLC as a whole or for a series separately. An effective statement of authority is conclusive in favor of a person that gives value in reliance on the statement, unless the person has knowledge to the contrary. The statement of authority is mostly likely useful for situations where a third party is seeking clear authority in a public record, as opposed to having to get assurances that do not appear on the public record. One example would be real estate conveyancing.
Finally, it is worth mentioning that, like the prior statute, the new Act provides for certain actions that cannot be taken or authorized by any person without consent of all of the members of the LLC, such as amending the operating agreement or filing for bankruptcy. However, the “default” nature of the new Act suggests that this requirement may be varied by an agreement among the members to give such authority to fewer than all of the members or even to another person, such as a manager.
Key takeaways. The management structure of an LLC can be a touchy subject, so if your operating agreement has provisions that work well to the general satisfaction of all involved, there is probably no good reason to make any changes based on the new law. If, however, the current management structure is awkward, confusing, or poorly worded – either because ideas were forced to fit into the more restrictive concepts of the existing Ohio law or because the structure has become outdated for the business – now is the ideal time to revisit it in view of the flexibility of the new Act. Closely related and also worthy of consideration are the types of duties owed by members and managers to the LLC and to the other members. For a discussion of that subject, click here. Finally, going forward, a party dealing with an LLC may want to take a closer look for actual authority before entering into an agreement.
For more information, please contact:
This Client Alert has been prepared by Tucker Ellis LLP for the use of our clients. Although prepared by professionals, it should not be used as a substitute for legal counseling in specific situations. Readers should not act upon the information contained herein without professional guidance.